Home / Articles / Lewis acid mediated rearrangements of dispiro[2.1.2.0]heptane-4,4-dicarboxylate: evidence for non-classical behavior of 2-cyclopropylallyl carbocation

Lewis acid mediated rearrangements of dispiro[2.1.2.0]heptane-4,4-dicarboxylate: evidence for non-classical behavior of 2-cyclopropylallyl carbocation

0
Cite this
GOST
 | 
Cite this
GOST
Potapov K. V. et al. Lewis acid mediated rearrangements of dispiro[2.1.2.0]heptane-4,4-dicarboxylate: evidence for non-classical behavior of 2-cyclopropylallyl carbocation // Mendeleev Communications. 2026.
GOST all authors (up to 50)
Potapov K. V., Novikov M. A., Novikov R. A., Tomilov Y. V. Lewis acid mediated rearrangements of dispiro[2.1.2.0]heptane-4,4-dicarboxylate: evidence for non-classical behavior of 2-cyclopropylallyl carbocation // Mendeleev Communications. 2026.
RIS
 | 
Cite this
RIS
TY - JOUR
DO - 10.71267/mencom.8119
UR - https://mendcomm.colab.ws/publications/10.71267/mencom.8119
TI - Lewis acid mediated rearrangements of dispiro[2.1.2.0]heptane-4,4-dicarboxylate: evidence for non-classical behavior of 2-cyclopropylallyl carbocation
T2 - Mendeleev Communications
AU - Potapov, K. V.
AU - Novikov, M. A.
AU - Novikov, R. A.
AU - Tomilov, Yu. V.
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/09
PB - Mendeleev Communications
ER -
BibTex
Cite this
BibTex (up to 50 authors)
@article{2026_Potapov,
author = {K. V. Potapov and M. A. Novikov and R. A. Novikov and Yu. V. Tomilov},
title = {Lewis acid mediated rearrangements of dispiro[2.1.2.0]heptane-4,4-dicarboxylate: evidence for non-classical behavior of 2-cyclopropylallyl carbocation},
journal = {Mendeleev Communications},
year = {2026},
publisher = {Mendeleev Communications},
month = {Oct},
url = {https://mendcomm.colab.ws/publications/10.71267/mencom.8119},
doi = {10.71267/mencom.8119}
}
Views / Downloads
66 / 36

Abstract

Dimethyl dispiro[2.1.2.0]heptane-4,4-dicarboxylate containing three spiro-linked cyclopropane rings has been proven to be a valuable building block for the Lewis acid catalyzed rearrangements to give a set of products involving the cleavage of two or three cyclopropane rings. Among various Lewis acids tested, GaCl3 was able to selectively generate a non-classical 2-cyclopropylallyl carbocation that further isomerized to produce (3-methylcyclopent-2-enylidene)malonate as almost exclusive product.

Keywords

carbocation rearrangements
dispiro[2.1.2.0]heptane-4,4-dicarboxylate
Lewis acids
methylenespiro[2.3]hexanes
non-classical carbocations
ring expansion

Communication

Donor–acceptor cyclopropanes (DACs) are widely used in modern synthetic chemistry as valuable building blocks due to their unique reactivity caused by the presence of vicinally-positioned electron-donor and electron-withdrawing substituents on the cyclopropane ring.[1-3] Most common Lewis acid mediated ring-opening transformations of DACs involve reactions of nucleophilic or electrophilic addition, (3 + n)-cycloadditions, annulations and other transformations, where DAC is serving as a formal synthetic equivalent of 1,3-dipole.[4-10]

Donor–acceptor cyclopropanes containing one or more additional small cycles are of particular interest due to their increased ring strain energy that should facilitate ring-opening rearrangements to cause additional more complicated cascade transformations. For instance, the reactions of spiro[2.2]pentanes (‘monospiro-DACs’) are well documented proceeding either with the second cyclopropane ring retained,[11-17] or with the cleavage of both of them.[18, 19] Rearrangements of polyspiroalkanes are also known and include only carbocationic[20-25] and radical transformations;[26] while the reactions of polycyclic DACs via zwitter-ionic intermediates are limited. We have recently demonstrated that DACs containing additional cycloalkane scaffolds either in linearly-arranged substituention or in a spiro-coupled fashion exhibited a wide variety of synthetic pathways. These include transformations via classical 1,3-zwitter-ionic intermediates proceeding with the only one three-membered ring cleavage, as well as more complex cascade rearrangements with the both rings cleaved via the formal generation of 1,n-zwitter-ionic intermediates (n = 2–6).[27-30]

In the current work, we have studied Lewis acid mediated rearrangements of a more complex spirocyclic scaffold consisting of three spiro-coupled cyclopropanes, namely, dimethyl dispiro[2.1.2.0]heptane-4,4-dicarboxylate 1 (Scheme 1). In fact, dispiroheptane 1 readily reacted with 1–2 equiv. of TiCl4 and SnCl4 with the full consumption over 1 h to afford malonate derivatives of 2-cyclopropylallyl chloride 2 and 4-methylenespiro[2.3]hexane 3 indicating that two of the three cyclopropane rings were cleaved (Scheme 1, Table 1, entries 1, 2).

Table 1
\[ \]
Product distribution in Lewis acid mediated rearrangements of 1.a
(1)

Scheme 1

Evidently, the formation of methylenecyclobutane 3 is the result of 1,2-alkyl shift in the intermediate A similarly to the rearrangements of spiro[2.n]alkane-1,1-dicarboxylates that we recently studied.[30] In turn, allyl chloride 2 is the product of formal nucleophilic addition of Lewis acid derived Cl– to the allyl intermediate B that might exist in the reaction mixture as a complex with Lewis acid (see Scheme 1, structure C). Replacing these Lewis acids with EtAlCl2 and Et2AlCl led to significant increase in the reaction selectivity affording allyl chloride 2 as the predominant product (see Table 1, entries 3, 4). The use of 0.1 equiv. of Yb(NTf2)3 or HNTf2 (which do not contain nucleophilic anions) as the catalysts prevents the formation of allyl chloride 2 in favor of lactone 4 as the product of the O-cyclization of intermediate B (entries 6, 7). Furthermore, in the case of Yb(NTf2)3 the yield of the C-cyclization product, 6-methylenespiro[2.3]hexane-4,4-dicarboxylate 5 that is an isomer of 3, is notable (entry 6).

Using significantly stronger Lewis acids such as GaCl3 and AlCl3 revealed an unusual reaction pathway. For instance, when 1 equiv. of GaCl3 or AlCl3 was used, products 2 and 3 were formed similarly to TiCl4 and SnCl4 mediated reactions (Table 2, entries 1, 3). However, when the amount of GaCl3 or AlCl3 was raised from 1 to 2 equiv. the reaction proceeded differently: the fractions of compounds 2 and 3 dropped significantly, and (3-methylcyclopent-2-en-1-ylidene)malonate 7 became the major product (Scheme 2, Table 2, entries 2, 4). Furthermore, in the case of GaCl3, very high selectivity could be achieved. Thus, a further increase in the amount of GaCl3 to 3 equiv. allows achieving a product ratio of 7 to 3 greater than 10 to 1 with only trace amounts of allyl chloride 2 (entry 5).

Scheme 2

Table 2
\[ \]
Product distribution in GaCl3/AlCl3-mediated rearrangements of 1.a
(2)

The methyl group position in the diene 7 has been unequivocally confirmed by 13C, COSY and HMBC NMR spectra (Figure 1). It is difficult to explain the formation of such a product in terms of classical carbocations. To clarify the formation mechanism, we conducted a control experiment by adding GaCl3 to DAC 1 in two portions of 1 equiv. each 1 h apart (see Table 2, entry 6). In this case, the first equivalent of GaCl3 generated a mixture of allyl chloride 2 and methylenecyclobutane 3 in the form of gallium complexes. Treatment with the second equivalent of GaCl3 led to the nearly complete disappearance of allyl chloride 2 and the formation of an equivalent amount of diene 7. This observation clearly indicates that the formation of diene 7 proceeds sequentially via an allyl intermediate (either allyl chloride 2 or allyl carbocation B). Note that the amount of methylenecyclobutane 3 also decreased by ~10%, which correlates with the overall decrease in yield, likely due to oligomerization.

Figure 1
13C NMR data and selected {1H,1H}-COSY and {1H,13C}-HMBC correlations. * Multiplicities from {1H, 13C} edited HSQC.

The observed virtually exclusive formation of diene 7 when 2–3 equiv. of GaCl3 are used immediately at the initial stage of the reaction, with products 2 and 3 being virtually absent, is likely due to the facilitated formation of complex C compared to the 1,2-alkyl shift in intermediate A. In turn, an excess of GaCl3 causes the conversion of complex C into the ionic intermediate D, which is essentially a nonclassical carbocation (Scheme 3).

Scheme 3

Thus, intermediate D has a structure that combines a malonate fragment, whose negative charge is compensated by the positive charge of the Ga3+ cation, and a (2-cyclopropyl)allyl carbocation fragment that is stabilized by a weakly coordinating polychlorogallate anion GaxCl– 3x + 1. The (2-cyclopropyl)allyl carbocation in D is also a β-cyclopropylcarbinyl carbocation, which is well known for its nonclassical nature from the works of Olah and Masamune.[31-33] The representation of this cation as resonance structures D–G reveals structure G, which is a precursor to the stable 1,2-zwitterionic gallium complex of the final diene 7 (see Scheme 3, structure H). Notably, the transition between resonance structures D–G occurs exclusively via the formation and cleavage of two-electron three-centered bonds, without any hydride shifts.[31-34] The formation of complex H is the driving force that determines the preferred resonance form of the nonclassical (2-cyclopropyl)allyl cation.

Additional experiments were conducted to investigate whether the intermediates A and B participate in the reaction and can be captured by a non-halogen nucleophile. In this way, we used 1 and 2 equiv. of Me3Al, which can serve as both a Lewis acid and a source of a formal methyl anion able to irreversibly quench the carbocation centers of the corresponding zwitter-ionic intermediates. Under these conditions, both expected products, 9 and 10, were obtained, while their ratio was practically independent on the amount of Me3Al used (Scheme 4).

Scheme 4

In summary, we have demonstrated that the ring-opening Lewis acid mediated rearrangements of dimethyl dispiro[2.1.2.0]heptane-4,4-dicarboxylate 1 occurs through the cleavage of two of its three cyclopropane rings via intermediates A–H. When 2 equiv. of GaCl3 or AlCl3 are used, the rearrangement proceeds further, involving the cleavage of the third cyclopropane ring, leading to 3-methylcyclopent-2-enylidene malonate 7 via a cascade of nonclassical carbocations.

This work was funded by The Russian Science Foundation (grant no. 25-13-00574). This work was performed using the equipment in the Shared Research Center (Department of Structural Studies) of N. D. Zelinsky Institute of Organic Chemistry RAS, Moscow.

Funders

Russian Science Foundation
25-13-00574

References

2.
A New Golden Age for Donor-Acceptor Cyclopropanes
Schneider T.F., Kaschel J., Werz D.B.
Angewandte Chemie - International Edition , 2014
3.
Research Progress on the Application of Donor–Acceptor Cyclopropanes in Cycloaddition/Annulation Reactions
5.
Catalytic Enantioselective Ring-Opening Reactions of Cyclopropanes
6.
Uncovering the Neglected Similarities of Arynes and Donor–Acceptor Cyclopropanes
Werz D.B., Biju A.T.
Angewandte Chemie - International Edition , 2019
7.
Ring Opening of Donor–Acceptor Cyclopropanes with N-Nucleo­philes
Budynina E., Ivanov K., Sorokin I., Melnikov M.
Synthesis , 2017
9.
Carbocycles from donor–acceptor cyclopropanes
Grover H.K., Emmett M.R., Kerr M.A.
Organic and Biomolecular Chemistry , 2015
10.
Intramolecular donor–acceptor cyclopropane ring-opening cyclizations
Cavitt M.A., Phun L.H., France S.
Chemical Society Reviews , 2014
11.
Synthesis of Enantiopure Indolizinones by Cascade Ring Enlargements of 4‘-Chlorospiro[cyclopropane-1,5‘-isoxazolidines]
Revuelta J., Cicchi S., Faggi C., Kozhushkov S.I., de Meijere A., Brandi A.
Journal of Organic Chemistry , 2006
12.
Reduction of 1-Nitrospiro[2.2]pentanecarboxylates: Convenient Synthesis of Novel Polyspirocyclic Cyclopropane Amino Acids
14.
SmI2-Catalyzed Intermolecular Coupling of Cyclopropyl Ketones and Alkynes: A Link between Ketone Conformation and Reactivity
Agasti S., Beattie N.A., McDouall J.J., Procter D.J.
Journal of the American Chemical Society , 2021
15.
Photocatalyzed [2σ + 2σ] and [2σ + 2π] Cycloadditions for the Synthesis of Bicyclo[3.1.1]heptanes and 5- or 6-Membered Carbocycles
16.
Homologation of Alkenyl Carbonyls via a Cyclopropanation/Light‐Mediated Selective C‐C Cleavage Strategy
Nguyen T.V., Brownsey D.K., Bossonnet A., Wodrich M.D., Waser J.
Angewandte Chemie - International Edition , 2024
19.
10.1002/(SICI)1099-0690(199911)1999:11\%3C3105::AID-EJOC3105\%3E3.0.CO
22.
Unusual rearrangement in the reaction of cyclopropanated cyclopentadienes with Et3Al/CH2I2 in CH2Cl2
Ramazanov I.R., Yaroslavova A.V., Yaubasarov N.R., Dzhemilev U.M.
Synthetic Communications , 2018
23.
Synthesis of Spiro[2.2]pentanes and Spiro[2.3]hexanes Employing the Me3 Al/CH2 I2 Reagent
Ramazanov I.R., Kadikova R.N., Zosim T.P., Dzhemilev U.M., de Meijere A.
European Journal of Organic Chemistry , 2017
24.
Relative Stabilities of Spirocyclopropanated Cyclopropyl Cations
Kozhushkov S., Späth T., Kosa M., Apeloig Y., Yufit D., de Meijere A.
European Journal of Organic Chemistry , 2003
27.
Denisov Dmitry Alekseevich, Borisov Denis Dmitrievich, Potapov Konstantin Vladislavovich, Novikov Roman Aleksandrovich, Tomilov Yury Vasil'evich
Mendeleev Communications , 2019
30.
Borisova Irina A, Potapov Konstantin Vladislavovich, Maximova Anna D, Novikov Maxim Alexandrovich, Novikov Roman Aleksandrovich, Tomilov Yury Vasil'evich
Mendeleev Communications , 2026
31.
Nonclassical Carbocations
Barkhash V.A.
Topics in Current Chemistry , 1984
32.
Stable carbocations. CXXXII. Protonated unsaturated aldehydes and ketones
Olah G.A., Halpern Y., Mo Y.K., Liang G.
Journal of the American Chemical Society , 1972
33.
The Trishomocyclopropenyl Cation. I. Direct Observation
Masamune S., Sakai M., Kemp-Jones A.V., Nakashima T.
Canadian Journal of Chemistry , 1974