Keywords
computational NMR
computer assisted structure elucidation
DP4-based probability methods
machine-learning
neural network
statistical methods
Abstract
The present review provides a brief summary of the most popular statistical protocols applied in the NMR spectral analysis: machine-learning, neural network, computer assisted structure elucidation, and DP4-based probability methods, which produced a real breakthrough in the interpretation of challenging NMR spectra. Those protocols are a broad family of related machine-learning and artificial neural network statistical treatments, the latter being on the cutting edge of modern statistical science providing an alternative to the state-of-the-art multidimensional NMR experiments, which are often combined with quantum chemical calculations at different levels of theory.
References
2.
Haapaniemi E.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2017
3.
Zubkov S.V., Golotvin S.S., Chertkov V.A.
Russian Chemical Bulletin,
2002
4.
Cheshkov D.A., Sinitsyn D.O., Sheberstov K.F., Chertkov V.A.
Journal of Magnetic Resonance,
2016
5.
Sheberstov K.F., Sinitsyn D.O., Cheshkov D.A., Jeannerat D.
Journal of Magnetic Resonance,
2017
6.
Cheshkov D.A., Sheberstov K.F., Sinitsyn D.O., Chertkov V.A.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2018
7.
Edgar M., Zeinali F., Mojally M., Hughes C., Riaz S., Weaver G.W.
Journal of Fluorine Chemistry,
2019
8.
Edgar M., Hayward D., Zeinali F., Riaz S., Weaver G.W.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2019
9.
Malkin V.G., Malkina O.L., Salahub D.R.
Chemical Physics Letters,
1993
10.
Malkin V.G., Malkina O.L., Casida M.E., Salahub D.R.
Journal of the American Chemical Society,
1994
11.
Malkin V.G., Malkina O.L., Salahub D.R.
Chemical Physics Letters,
1993
12.
Schreckenbach G., Ziegler T.
The Journal of Physical Chemistry,
1995
13.
Schreckenbach G., Ziegler T.
International Journal of Quantum Chemistry,
1996
14.
Schreckenbach G., Dickson R.M., Ruiz-Morales Y., Ziegler T.
ACS Symposium Series,
1996
15.
Schreckenbach G., Ziegler T.
International Journal of Quantum Chemistry,
1997
16.
Schreckenbach G., Ziegler T.
Theoretical Chemistry Accounts,
1998
17.
Lee A.M., Handy N.C., Colwell S.M.
Journal of Chemical Physics,
1995
18.
Olsson L., Cremer D.
Journal of Chemical Physics,
1996
19.
20.
Provasi P.F., Aucar G.A., Sauer S.P.
Journal of Chemical Physics,
2001
21.
Provasi P.F., Aucar G.A., Sauer S.P.
Journal of Chemical Physics,
2000
22.
Møller C. ., Sauer S. .
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2025
23.
Jessen L.M., Sauer S.P.
Journal of Chemical Physics,
2024
24.
Sanz Rodrigo J., Hillers-Bendtsen A.E., Kjeldal F.Ø., Høyer N.M., Mikkelsen K.V., Sauer S.P.
Journal of Chemical Physics,
2023
25.
Schnack-Petersen A.K., Simmermacher M., Fasshauer E., Jensen H.J., Sauer S.P.
Journal of Chemical Physics,
2020
26.
Faber R., Sauer S.P., Gauss J.
Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation,
2017
27.
Enevoldsen T., Oddershede J., Sauer S.P.
Theoretical Chemistry Accounts,
1998
28.
Oddershede J.
Cluster Models for Surface and Bulk Phenomena,
1992
29.
WIGGLESWORTH R.D., ODDERSHEDE W.T.
Molecular Physics,
1997
30.
R. D. WIGGLESWORTH W. T. RAYNES S.
Molecular Physics,
1998
31.
Wigglesworth R.D., Raynes W.T., Kirpekar S., Oddershede J., Sauer S.P.
Journal of Chemical Physics,
2000
32.
Nielsen E.S., Jo/rgensen P., Oddershede J.
Journal of Chemical Physics,
1980
33.
Bak K.L., Koch H., Oddershede J., Christiansen O., Sauer S.P.
Journal of Chemical Physics,
2000
34.
Kjær H., Sauer S.P., Kongsted J.
Journal of Chemical Physics,
2010
35.
Sauer S.P.
Journal of Physics B: Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics,
1997
37.
Klukowski P., Riek R., Güntert P.
Progress in Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy,
2025
38.
Cortés I., Cuadrado C., Hernández Daranas A., Sarotti A.M.
Frontiers in Natural Products,
2023
39.
Kuhn S.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2022
40.
Kuhn S., de Jesus R.P., Borges R.M.
Encyclopedia,
2024
41.
Sarotti A.M.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2020
42.
Hellwig J., Strauß T., von Harbou E., Neymeyr K.
Journal of Magnetic Resonance,
2025
43.
Hou Z., Jin Y., Gu Z., Zhang R., Su Z., Liu S.
Foods,
2024
44.
Chen D., Wang Z., Guo D., Orekhov V., Qu X.
Chemistry - A European Journal,
2020
45.
Qu X., Huang Y., Lu H., Qiu T., Guo D., Agback T., Orekhov V., Chen Z.
Angewandte Chemie - International Edition,
2020
46.
Deep learning network for NMR spectra reconstruction in time-frequency domain and quality assessment
Luo Y., Chen W., Su Z., Shi X., Luo J., Qu X., Chen Z., Lin Y.
Nature Communications,
2025
47.
Zhan H., Liu J., Fang Q., Chen X., Hu L.
Analytical Chemistry,
2024
48.
Kuhn S., Tumer E., Colreavy‐Donnelly S., Moreira Borges R.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2021
49.
Cobas C.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2020
50.
Amendolia S.R., Doppiu A., Ganadu M.L., Lubinu G.
Analytical Chemistry,
1998
51.
Kern S., Liehr S., Wander L., Bornemann-Pfeiffer M., Müller S., Maiwald M., Kowarik S.
Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry,
2020
52.
Karunanithy G., Hansen D.F.
Journal of Biomolecular NMR,
2021
53.
Shukla V.K., Karunanithy G., Vallurupalli P., Hansen D.F.
Science advances,
2024
54.
Li D., Hansen A.L., Yuan C., Bruschweiler-Li L., Brüschweiler R.
Nature Communications,
2021
55.
Kaneko M., Suzaki A., Muraoka A., Gotoh K., Yamashita K.
Journal of Materials Informatics,
2023
56.
Zhan H., Fang Q., Liu J., Shi X., Chen X., Huang Y., Chen Z.
Wuli Huaxue Xuebao/ Acta Physico - Chimica Sinica,
2025
57.
Spinelli G.V., Evangelista D., Hu L., Zama F.
Neural Computing and Applications,
2024
58.
Luo G., Bijeljic B., Luo S., Xiao L., Shao R., Blunt M.J.
Transport in Porous Media,
2025
59.
Jopa S., Bukowicki M., Shchukina A., Kazimierczuk K.
Journal of Physical Chemistry B,
2025
60.
Johnson H., Tipirneni-Sajja A.
Metabolites,
2025
61.
Xiao X., Wang Q., Chai X., Zhang X., Jiang B., Liu M.
Communications Chemistry,
2024
62.
Karunanithy G., Shukla V.K., Hansen D.F.
Nature Communications,
2024
63.
Johnson H., Tipirneni-Sajja A.
Metabolites,
2024
65.
Yang Z., Chakraborty M., White A.D.
Chemical Science,
2021
66.
Han J., Kang H., Kang S., Kwon Y.C., Lee D., Choi Y.
Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics,
2022
67.
Kim H.W., Zhang C., Cottrell G.W., Gerwick W.H.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2021
68.
Li C., Cong Y., Deng W.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2022
69.
Venetos M.C., Wen M., Persson K.A.
Journal of Physical Chemistry A,
2023
70.
Lederberg J., Sutherland G.L., Buchanan B.G., Feigenbaum E.A., Robertson A.V., Duffield A.M., Djerassi C.
Journal of the American Chemical Society,
1969
71.
Nelson D.B., Munk M.E., Gash K.B., Herald D.L.
Journal of Organic Chemistry,
1969
72.
Sasaki S., Abe H., Ouki T., Sakamoto M., Ochiai S.
Analytical Chemistry,
1968
73.
Elyashberg M.E., Gribov L.A.
Journal of Applied Spectroscopy,
1968
74.
Elyashberg M.E., Williams A., Blinov K.
2011
75.
Elyashberg M.E., Williams A.J.
2015
76.
Buevich A.V., Elyashberg M.E.
Journal of Natural Products,
2016
77.
Elyashberg M., Argyropoulos D.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2020
78.
Buevich A.V., Elyashberg M.E.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2020
79.
Elyashberg M., Williams A.J., Blinov K.
Natural Product Reports,
2010
80.
Elyashberg M.E.
Russian Chemical Reviews,
1999
81.
Hanssen K.Ø., Schuler B., Williams A.J., Demissie T.B., Hansen E., Andersen J.H., Svenson J., Blinov K., Repisky M., Mohn F., Meyer G., Svendsen J., Ruud K., Elyashberg M., Gross L., et. al.
Angewandte Chemie - International Edition,
2012
82.
Saranya N.S., Choudhury R., Supekar P.R., Beduru S., Williams C.M., Elyashberg M.E., Kutateladze A.G., Bates R.W., Reddy D.S.
Journal of Natural Products,
2025
83.
Elyashberg M.E., Kutateladze A.G., Bates R.W., Williams C.M.
Fitoterapia,
2025
84.
Bates R.W., Williams C.M., Kutateladze A.G., Elyashberg M.
Fitoterapia,
2025
85.
Bates R.W., Elyashberg M., Kutateladze A.G., Williams C.M.
European Journal of Organic Chemistry,
2024
86.
Novitskiy I.M., Elyashberg M., Bates R.W., Kutateladze A.G., Williams C.M.
Organic Letters,
2023
87.
Kutateladze A.G., Bates R.W., Elyashberg M., Williams C.M.
European Journal of Organic Chemistry,
2023
88.
Bates R.W., Elyashberg M., Khandare S.P., Appendino G., Kutateladze A.G., Williams C.M.
Organic Letters,
2025
89.
Navarro-Vázquez A.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2019
90.
Bates R.W., Elyashberg M., Kutateladze A.G., Williams C.M.
European Journal of Organic Chemistry,
2023
91.
Elyashberg M., Tyagarajan S., Mandal M., Buevich A.V.
Molecules,
2023
92.
Trac A., Issaad C., Beniddir M.A., Bellanger J., Gallard J., Buevich A.V., Elyashberg M.E., Le Pogam P.
Molecules,
2023
93.
Ferron S., Ismed F., Elyashberg M.E., Buevich A.V., Arifa N., Boustie J., Uriac P., Le Pogam P., Le Dévéhat F.
Journal of Natural Products,
2024
94.
Marcarino M.O., Cicetti S., Zanardi M.M., Sarotti A.M.
Natural Product Reports,
2022
95.
Ermanis K., Parkes K.E., Agback T., Goodman J.M.
Organic and Biomolecular Chemistry,
2019
96.
Howarth A., Ermanis K., Goodman J.M.
Chemical Science,
2020
97.
Grimblat N., Zanardi M.M., Sarotti A.M.
Journal of Organic Chemistry,
2015
98.
Grimblat N., Gavín J.A., Hernández Daranas A., Sarotti A.M.
Organic Letters,
2019
99.
Xin D., Jones P., Gonnella N.C.
Journal of Organic Chemistry,
2018
100.
Pinto B.N., Teixeira M.G., Alvarenga E.S.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2020
101.
Santos F.M., Silva Mota G.V., Martorano L.H., Albuquerque A.C., Silva C.A., Silva A.M., Jesus Chaves Neto A.M., Valverde A.L., Cardoso E.F., Costa F.L.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2022
102.
Martorano L.H., Brito J.T., Albuquerque A.C., Ribeiro C.M., Fiorot R.G., Carneiro J.W., Costa F.L., Valverde A.L., Santos Junior F.M.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2021
103.
Rzepa H.S., Kuhn S.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2021
104.
Chhaganlal M.N., Underhaug J., Mjøs S.A.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2023
105.
Nuzillard J.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2023
106.
Martins L.M., Souto F.T., Hoye T.R., Alvarenga E.S.
Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry,
2024